Private roads access with racingbike & motorcycle

Hello,

First of all, thank you for this amazing software and documentation. I was able to launch a GraphHopper instance very smoothly.

However, I am facing an issue with private roads access. It works as expected for the foot, bike and mtb profiles, but not for the racingbike and motorcycle ones.

See: bike vs racingbike

I have added the |block_private=false suffix to car_access, foot_access, bike_access, mtb_access and racingbike_access in the config file. Is there anything I am missing?

If it helps, my current configuration uses no CH and no LM.

Thank you in advance!

If it helps, here is my current config file:

graphhopper:

  # OpenStreetMap input file PBF or XML, can be changed via command line -Ddw.graphhopper.datareader.file=some.pbf
  datareader.file: ""
  # Local folder used by graphhopper to store its data
  graph.location: graph-cache


  ##### Routing Profiles ####

  # Routing can be done only for profiles listed below. For more information about profiles and custom profiles have a
  # look into the documentation at docs/core/profiles.md or the examples under web/src/test/java/com/graphhopper/application/resources/
  # or the CustomWeighting class for the raw details.
  #
  # In general a profile consists of the following
  # - name (required): a unique string identifier for the profile
  # - weighting (optional): by default 'custom'
  # - turn_costs (optional):
  #     vehicle_types: [motorcar, motor_vehicle] (vehicle types used for vehicle-specific turn restrictions)
  #     u_turn_costs: 60 (time-penalty for doing a u-turn in seconds)
  #
  # Depending on the above fields there are other properties that can be used, e.g.
  # - custom_model_files: when you specified "weighting: custom" you need to set one or more json files which are searched in
  #   custom_models.directory or the working directory that defines the custom_model. If you want an empty model you can
  #   set "custom_model_files: []
  #   You can also use the `custom_model` field instead and specify your custom model in the profile directly.
  #
  # To prevent long running routing queries you should usually enable either speed or hybrid mode for all the given
  # profiles (see below). Or at least limit the number of `routing.max_visited_nodes`.

  profiles:
#   - name: car
#     turn_costs:
#       vehicle_types: [motorcar, motor_vehicle]
#       u_turn_costs: 60
#     for more advanced turn costs see avoid_turns.json
#     custom_model_files: [car.json]

#   You can use the following in-built profiles. After you start GraphHopper it will print which encoded values you'll have to add to graph.encoded_values in this config file.
#
   - name: foot
     custom_model_files: [hike.json, foot_elevation.json]

   - name: bike
     custom_model_files: [bike.json, bike_elevation.json]

   - name: racingbike
     custom_model_files: [racingbike.json, bike_elevation.json]

   - name: mtb
     custom_model_files: [mtb.json, bike_elevation.json]
    
   - name: motorcycle
     custom_model_files: [motorcycle.json, curvature.json]
#
#    - name: custom_profile
#      navigation_mode: bike
#      turn_costs:
#        vehicle_types: [bicycle]
#        u_turn_costs: 10
#      custom_model_files: [your_custom_model.json]
#
#    # See the bus.json for more details.
#    - name: bus
#      turn_costs:
#        vehicle_types: [bus, motor_vehicle]
#        u_turn_costs: 60
#      custom_model_files: [bus.json]
#
#   You can configure a profile with turn costs like "3 seconds for left" and "5 seconds for right turns" via:
#    1. add the turn_costs entry to the profile (see e.g. the car profile)
#    2. add orientation to the graph.encoded_values list
#    3. add avoid_turns.json to the custom_model_files
#   Edit avoid_turns.json or create your own JSON file and put it into the "custom_models.directory". See also bike_tc.yml.
#
#   Other custom models not listed here are: car4wd.json, motorcycle.json, truck.json or cargo-bike.json. You might need to modify and test them before production usage.
#   See ./core/src/main/resources/com/graphhopper/custom_models and let us know if you customize them, improve them or create new onces!
#   Also there is the curvature.json custom model which might be useful for a motorcyle profile or the opposite for a truck profile.
#   Then specify a folder where to find your own custom model files:
#  custom_models.directory: custom_models


  # Speed mode:
  # It's possible to speed up routing by doing a special graph preparation (Contraction Hierarchies, CH). This requires
  # more RAM/disk space for holding the prepared graph but also means less memory usage per request. Using the following
  # list you can define for which of the above routing profiles such preparation shall be performed. Note that to support
  # profiles with `turn_costs` a more elaborate preparation is required (longer preparation time and more memory
  # usage) and the routing will also be slower than without `turn_costs`.
  # profiles_ch:
  #   - profile: car

  # Hybrid mode:
  # Similar to speed mode, the hybrid mode (Landmarks, LM) also speeds up routing by doing calculating auxiliary data
  # in advance. Its not as fast as speed mode, but more flexible.
  #
  # Advanced usage: It is possible to use the same preparation for multiple profiles which saves memory and preparation
  # time. To do this use e.g. `preparation_profile: my_other_profile` where `my_other_profile` is the name of another
  # profile for which an LM profile exists. Important: This only will give correct routing results if the weights
  # calculated for the profile are equal or larger (for every edge) than those calculated for the profile that was used
  # for the preparation (`my_other_profile`)
  # profiles_lm: []


  #### Encoded Values ####

  # Add additional information to every edge. Used for path details (#1548) and custom models (docs/core/custom-models.md)
  # Possible values: road_class,road_class_link,road_environment,max_speed,road_access
  #   surface,smoothness,max_width,max_height,max_weight,max_weight_except,hgv,max_axle_load,max_length,
  #   hazmat,hazmat_tunnel,hazmat_water,lanes,osm_way_id,toll,track_type,mtb_rating,hike_rating,horse_rating,
  #   country,curvature,average_slope,max_slope,car_temporal_access,bike_temporal_access,foot_temporal_access
  # Private roads are blocked by default to disable this you can specify (also applies to other access encoded values like bike_access):
  #   car_access|block_private=false
  graph.encoded_values: >
    road_access, track_type, road_class, curvature, surface, average_slope, roundabout, country,
    car_access|block_private=false, car_average_speed,
    foot_network,
    foot_access|block_private=false, foot_priority, foot_average_speed, foot_road_access, hike_rating,
    bike_network,
    bike_priority, bike_access|block_private=false, bike_average_speed, bike_road_access,
    mtb_priority, mtb_access|block_private=false, mtb_average_speed, mtb_rating,
    racingbike_priority, racingbike_access|block_private=false, racingbike_average_speed,

  #### Speed, hybrid and flexible mode ####

  # To make CH preparation faster for multiple profiles you can increase the default threads if you have enough RAM.
  # Change this setting only if you know what you are doing and if the default worked for you.
  # prepare.ch.threads: 1

  # To tune the performance vs. memory usage for the hybrid mode use
  # prepare.lm.landmarks: 16

  # Make landmark preparation parallel if you have enough RAM. Change this only if you know what you are doing and if
  # the default worked for you.
  # prepare.lm.threads: 1


  #### Elevation ####

  # To populate your graph with elevation data use SRTM, default is noop (no elevation). Read more about it in docs/core/elevation.md
  graph.elevation.provider: srtm

  # default location for cache is /tmp/srtm
  # graph.elevation.cache_dir: ./srtmprovider/

  # If you have a slow disk or plenty of RAM change the default MMAP to:
  # graph.elevation.dataaccess: RAM_STORE

  # To enable bilinear interpolation when sampling elevation at points (default uses nearest neighbor):
  graph.elevation.interpolate: bilinear

  # Reduce ascend/descend per edge without changing the maximum slope:
  # graph.elevation.edge_smoothing: ramer
  # removes elevation fluctuations up to max_elevation (in meter) and replaces the elevation with a value based on the average slope
  # graph.elevation.edge_smoothing.ramer.max_elevation: 5
  # Using an averaging approach for smoothing will reveal values not affected by outliers and realistic slopes and total altitude values (up and down)
  # graph.elevation.edge_smoothing: moving_average
  # window size in meter along a way used for averaging a node's elevation
  # graph.elevation.edge_smoothing.moving_average.window_size: 150

  # To increase elevation profile resolution, use the following two parameters to tune the extra resolution you need
  # against the additional storage space used for edge geometries. You should enable bilinear interpolation when using
  # these features (see #1953 for details).
  # - first, set the distance (in meters) at which elevation samples should be taken on long edges
  graph.elevation.long_edge_sampling_distance: 60
  # - second, set the elevation tolerance (in meters) to use when simplifying polylines since the default ignores
  #   elevation and will remove the extra points that long edge sampling added
  graph.elevation.way_point_max_distance: 10


  #### Country-dependent defaults for max speeds ####

  # This features sets a maximum speed in 'max_speed' encoded value if no maxspeed tag was found. It is country-dependent
  # and based on several rules. See https://github.com/westnordost/osm-legal-default-speeds
  # To use it uncomment the following, then enable urban density below and add 'country' to graph.encoded_values
  # max_speed_calculator.enabled: true


  #### Urban density (built-up areas) ####

  # This feature allows classifying roads into 'rural', 'residential' and 'city' areas (encoded value 'urban_density')
  # Use 1 or more threads to enable the feature
  # graph.urban_density.threads: 4
  # Use higher/lower sensitivities if too little/many roads fall into the according categories.
  # Using smaller radii will speed up the classification, but only change these values if you know what you are doing.
  # If you do not need the (rather slow) city classification set city_radius to zero.
  # graph.urban_density.residential_radius: 400
  # graph.urban_density.residential_sensitivity: 6000
  # graph.urban_density.city_radius: 1500
  # graph.urban_density.city_sensitivity: 1000


  #### Subnetworks ####

  # In many cases the road network consists of independent components without any routes going in between. In
  # the most simple case you can imagine an island without a bridge or ferry connection. The following parameter
  # allows setting a minimum size (number of edges) for such detached components. This can be used to reduce the number
  # of cases where a connection between locations might not be found.
  prepare.min_network_size: 200
  prepare.subnetworks.threads: 1

  #### Routing ####

  # You can define the maximum visited nodes when routing. This may result in not found connections if there is no
  # connection between two points within the given visited nodes. The default is Integer.MAX_VALUE. Useful for flexibility mode
  # routing.max_visited_nodes: 1000000

  # default for snap_preventions
  routing.snap_preventions_default: tunnel, bridge, ferry

  # The maximum time in milliseconds after which a routing request will be aborted. This has some routing algorithm
  # specific caveats, but generally it should allow the prevention of long-running requests. The default is Long.MAX_VALUE
  routing.timeout_ms: 10000

  # Control how many active landmarks are picked per default, this can improve query performance
  # routing.lm.active_landmarks: 4

  # You can limit the max distance between two consecutive waypoints of flexible routing requests to be less or equal
  # the given distance in meter. Default is set to 1000km.
  routing.non_ch.max_waypoint_distance: 1000000


  #### Storage ####

  # Excludes certain types of highways during the OSM import to speed up the process and reduce the size of the graph.
  # A typical application is excluding 'footway','cycleway','path' and maybe 'track' highways for
  # motorized vehicles. This leads to a smaller and less dense graph, because there are fewer ways (obviously),
  # but also because there are fewer crossings between highways (=junctions).
  # Another typical example is excluding 'motorway', 'trunk' and maybe 'primary' highways for bicycle or pedestrian routing.
  # import.osm.ignored_highways: footway,construction,cycleway,path,steps # typically useful for motorized-only routing
  # import.osm.ignored_highways: motorway,trunk # typically useful for non-motorized routing
  import.osm.ignored_highways:

  # configure the memory access, use RAM_STORE for well equipped servers (default and recommended)
  graph.dataaccess.default_type: MMAP

  # will write way names in the preferred language (language code as defined in ISO 639-1 or ISO 639-2):
  # datareader.preferred_language: en

  #### Custom Areas ####

  # GraphHopper reads GeoJSON polygon files including their properties from this directory and makes them available
  # to all tag parsers and custom models. All GeoJSON Features require to have the "id" property.
  # Country borders are included automatically (see countries.geojson).
  # custom_areas.directory: path/to/custom_areas


  #### Country Rules ####

  # GraphHopper applies country-specific routing rules during import (not enabled by default).
  # You need to redo the import for changes to take effect.
  # country_rules.enabled: true

# Dropwizard server configuration
server:
  application_connectors:
  - type: http
    port: 8989
    # bind to all interfaces to allow access from outside the container
    bind_host: 0.0.0.0
    # increase GET request limit - not necessary if /maps UI is not used or used without custom models
    max_request_header_size: 50k
  request_log:
      appenders: []
  admin_connectors:
  - type: http
    port: 8990
    bind_host: localhost
# See https://www.dropwizard.io/en/latest/manual/core.html#logging
logging:
  appenders:
    - type: file
      time_zone: UTC
      current_log_filename: logs/graphhopper.log
      log_format: "%d{yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.SSS} [%thread] %-5level %logger{36} - %msg%n"
      archive: true
      archived_log_filename_pattern: ./logs/graphhopper-%d.log.gz
      archived_file_count: 30
      never_block: true
    - type: console
      time_zone: UTC
      log_format: "%d{yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.SSS} [%thread] %-5level %logger{36} - %msg%n"
  loggers:
    "com.graphhopper.osm_warnings":
      level: DEBUG
      additive: false
      appenders:
        - type: file
          currentLogFilename: logs/osm_warnings.log
          archive: false
          logFormat: '[%level] %msg%n'

On the official instance, the correct route is found for the racingbike profile

Which version are you using? It seems it is not the latest master. I tested with your config and detected that you are missing road_environment, mtb_network, in your graph.encoded_values: setting. With this change the result is the same as compared to the online instance.

It works indeed, thank you very much! I was using the last Docker image available on DockerHub, I am now building GraphHopper from master.